Assignment 1: Response to Tutor Feedback

The Art of Photography

Feedback and changes to Assignment 1: Contrasts

I  started on Part 2 of TAOP as soon as I had sent off Assignment 1 to my tutor.  Completing all the exercises and Assignment for Part 2, followed by the work on exercises and Assignment for Part 3, has meant that I haven’t given as much attention as I wanted to making any additions/changes.

I was pleased that the specific feedback was generally positive in terms of images produced;  how they met the brief; print quality/layout and also my blog.

Some suggestions for improvement were made though:-

Rounded:

“You’ve taken a lot of trouble with this image but as you say, it was difficult to get the angles you needed.  This might have been a case of going for a different, simpler more abstract image.  You had one on your blog!”

It is rounded of course and it was taken after I had submitted Assignment   1.

This is the top of the arch

I decided that I still wanted to have something even rounder which would, somehow, represent a contrast to the hard diagonals of the Gherkin.  There are two possibilities so far:-

A terracotta, celtic  cross surmounted a gravestone in Watts cemetery which is a small peaceful place  in Compton, Surrey .

The London Eye which is not only round but very large.

Still/moving:

Still

 “…it’s a very interesting image which communicates powerfully.  Very well observed”.  However, the suggestion was made that the  image might have worked even better framed more  tightly and, of course, it’s much better to do this in camera rather than cropping afterwards.

original image:-

I did further cropping to this:-

Obviously I could have cropped to just the girl but I still wanted to see some kind of context for her.

Still/Moving/Both in one picture

It was pointed out that I had “fallen into the trap of assuming that the viewer will associate that the people walking are ‘moving’, when in fact the camera has frozen their movement”.  I’ve had another go at this and the lady with the pram actually stood still whilst I took the picture.

Large/Small

Thought to work quite well but including other distracting elements in the frame. My tutor thought that another image in one of my blog posts (of an air balloon in Egypt) communicated both large and small.  I’m still thinking around this one and keeping it in mind when I’m out photographing but haven’t found what I think is a good one as yet.  The London Eye is certainly large but it isn’t contrasted against anything small.

Transparent/Opaque

My tutor suggested that I have a look at the work of Lee Friedlander and the way in which he fragments the world in his photography through various means. She linked this with a comment I’d made on my blog in quoting from an article by Dziga Vertov, a Soviet film director.  Vertov compares the effect of perspective in drawings and paintings (which proposed that the spectator was the unique centre of the world) against that of the camera, particularly the movie camera, which ‘demonstrated that there was no centre’. Do I feel that Friedlander’s work might  fit this theory? This is a difficult one because  I think that Friedlander’s work is so very different.  The feeling I get when viewing his images is of being alongside him, looking from inside out.  His perceived world, as seen through his camera, is right in front of my eyes. I don’t just see straight ahead. It’s as if I’m turning my head to take in a multiplicity of viewpoints. I think he’s got quite stuck in my head because, recently, I was experimenting with b+w conversion and posted this on my Flickr stream.

Some comments likened this to a British version of Friedlander’s ‘America by car”. A pale imitation, but I’m realising that I do feel drawn towards juxtaposed images, reflections and frames within frames and this is slowly creeping into my photography.

15th August 2011

Additional Thoughts 28th May 2012

Rounded

I am going to go with the Celtic cross which contrasts in many ways with the Gherkin. Both are ‘man-made’ but the one is by hand and the other by both men and machine.

Still

I will leave this as it stands.  Tighter framing is still something that I’m working on.

Still/Moving

I’m not happy with  the one above as there isn’t enough stillness there.  Wondered if this might be a better one:-

You can see by the blur that the people in the chairs are definitely moving whilst other people are standing there.

Large/Small

I still haven’t really come across a situation with such a juxtaposition which really appeals to me. It was this type of scene I was thinking of

This shows the immensity of the lower facade and entrance to La Sagrada Familia, Gaudi’s famous basilica in Barcelona. This is an old photograph from a compact camera so I wouldn’t submit this, but it gives an idea of what I’ve been looking for.

Advertisements

4 Comments on “Assignment 1: Response to Tutor Feedback”

  1. Amano says:

    In regards to “Rounded” I wonder if you have come across Lens Correction in either Lightroom or Camera RAW; it is very good at removing parallax in images.
    Amano

    • Thanks for reminding me Amano. If I do eventually use it (which I probably won’t) my intention is to crop to just the rounded arch. Hope all is well with you. I keep checking your blog but you don’t seem to have posted recently.
      PS – Realised I inserted the vertical image instead of the arch (which I had actually cropped for one of the exercises). Here is the arch.

  2. John Umney says:

    Hello Catherine, I’m on the way with my “Contrasts” so I read with interest you latest update. I’m with you on the framing of the sitter for the “Still” image – with the crop you’ve got now (and perhaps even with the original crop) th expectation is with the viewer to develop the notion of serenity or peacefullness as it doesn’t exist in the frame. I don’t think it would matter if there was nothing around the sitter or a tremendous hub-bub – it is, as you say, some context to apply to it. And I do like your reflection image. John

    • Hi John, Hope you enjoyed your holiday. I keep thinking more and more about’ still’. Maybe I’m wanting some context because the young woman is sitting in her own world, looking for contact within her phone, yet there she is with things going on around her. Catherine


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s